Internal Investigations at Work: Legal Issues Business Professionals Should Understand

Learn key legal considerations for internal workplace investigations, including documentation, confidentiality, interviewing practices, and compliance strategies to reduce risk and ensure fair outcomes.
Internal Investigations at Work: Legal Issues Business Professionals Should Understand

When allegations of wrongdoing or misconduct arise in the workplace, business professionals must navigate the complex legal landscape while performing proper internal investigations. For those in compliance, risk mitigation, and other law-adjacent roles, this requires a robust understanding of the workplace investigation process, confidentiality concerns, and documentation and reporting.

Why Internal Investigations Matter in Day-To-Day Business Operations

Internal investigations are an important aspect of any effective corporate governance strategy. Addressing issues before they snowball into larger problems can help businesses mitigate risk and support operational integrity. At the same time, transparent and unbiased internal investigations can build trust between employees and employers while providing legal protection. Without proper policies and procedures for handling internal investigations, businesses could open themselves up to liability and legal trouble down the road.

The Workplace Investigation Process Often Starts Before a Formal Review Begins

Businesses have an ethical and legal obligation to investigate issues, even if a formal complaint hasn't been raised through HR. Often, this requires careful listening, thorough documentation, and proactive issue framing.

Initial Documentation, Early Reporting, and Issue Framing

During the early stages of an investigation (and sometimes before a formal investigation is even launched), businesses should document potential issues. For example, they might establish a master log of evidence and gather relevant documentation, such as workplace policies and personnel files.

If an initial assessment indicates that a formal investigation is warranted, businesses should file reports quickly and initiate the process. This may include identifying the team that will conduct the investigation, as well as considering the need for voluntary self-disclosure.

Interview Procedures Can Affect Fairness, Consistency, and Credibility

When it comes time to interview team members or witnesses related to the investigation, employers must take special care to ensure fairness and defensibility. With the proper procedures in place, businesses can avoid issues such as biased inquiry and subjectivity.

Questioning, Note-Taking, and Process Structure

During workplace investigation interviews, teams should leverage objective and non-accusatory questioning techniques. Often, this begins with asking more open-ended questions to establish a general account of the person's experience, followed by more closed-ended questions to gather specific details.

Note-taking is also crucial. For each interview, the date, location, time, and people in attendance should be recorded, as well as:

  • Verbatim quotes (no paraphrasing)
  • Objective facts (not conclusions or deductions)
  • Exact questions asked

Using these best practices, investigators can mitigate potential claims of misrepresentation or bias. In some cases, it may be appropriate to record interviews for future reference or note-taking — but this should only be done with permission from all parties.

Confidentiality Concerns Require Careful Judgment, Not Blanket Assumptions

Throughout many internal investigations, confidentiality remains a major concern — especially for reporting employees who may be worried about retaliation or other repercussions. Although confidentiality may not be 100% guaranteed in any investigation, employers can take reasonable steps to protect those involved, such as by safeguarding documentation and implementing anti-retaliation policies.

At the same time, blanket rules calling for total confidentiality can create problems. In fact, these kinds of rules are often considered illegal by the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB). Consequently, employers need to approach confidentiality in investigations on a case-by-case basis, carefully considering all the nuances that can come into play.

Reporting Structure Can Shape How Internal Issues Are Escalated and Reviewed

Another consideration to keep in mind when handling corporate compliance investigations is how reporting structures can affect the escalation and review process. Some common reporting structures used by businesses include:

  • Hierarchical - Issues move from one level of hierarchy to the next (such as from supervisor to manager and manager to director). This process can be effective, but it also increases the risk of unwanted information filtering.
  • Horizontal - Issues are conveyed directly to senior leadership. This process allows for quick reporting, but it may not be practical for all businesses.
  • Functional - Issues are addressed within their relevant departments, allowing for more specialized reviews and investigations.

Ultimately, there's no "one-size-fits-all" reporting structure. Rather, businesses are encouraged to consider factors such as size and number of departments before determining the reporting structure that best suits their needs.

Follow-Up Decisions Can Carry Legal and Operational Weight

As internal investigations wrap up and findings are reviewed, follow-up decisions are critical. Not only can this decision-making help address workplace concerns, but it can also protect businesses from legal liability.

Why Consistency Matters After the Facts Are Reviewed

If issues are escalated to the legal system after an internal report, consistency often forms the basis for a defensible investigation. When businesses follow documented procedures for investigating complaints, applying corrective action, and maintaining records, they may be better positioned to protect themselves in the event of a lawsuit.

In addition to providing legal defensibility and mitigating risks, consistency can strengthen workplace culture by building trust between employees and management.

Corporate Compliance Investigations Often Involve More Than One Team

When the need for corporate compliance investigations arises, businesses often rely on expertise from more than one team — even when issues stem from a single department.

Why Internal Issues Rarely Stay in One Department

Many investigations include members of human resources, operations, compliance, and leadership teams. By having multiple teams involved in the investigation, businesses can maintain a better sense of objectivity and reduce the risk of bias or conflicts of interest. Furthermore, diverse investigation teams bring extensive experience to the table, which may help when navigating complex legal and compliance issues.

Key Takeaways for Professionals Involved in Workplace Reviews

Those involved in internal investigations should follow proper procedures based on:

  • The reporting structure of the business
  • Industry-specific compliance laws and legal requirements
  • The teams involved (HR, leadership, compliance, etc.)

Through carefully crafted and intentional investigation procedures, businesses can protect themselves from legal challenges, maintain confidentiality (where appropriate), and support corporate compliance — all while getting to the root of potential problems.

Build Stronger Business Judgment with Miami Law’s Online Master of Legal Studies

Navigating the complexities of corporate compliance and internal investigations can be challenging — but the right education and training can make all the difference. Specifically, those in law-adjacent business, compliance, HR, and investigation roles can benefit from the legal knowledge and skills gained in an online Master of Legal Studies program at the University of Miami School of Law.

In this program's General Track, professionals build essential skills and expertise in topics such as:

  • Enterprise risk management
  • Corporate compliance
  • U.S. law and regulation

By learning to analyze and communicate about the laws and regulations impacting your industry, you can navigate the workplace investigation process with greater confidence or even pursue advancement in your field.

Discover More in an M.L.S. Program at Miami Law

At the University of Miami School of Law, our online Master of Legal Studies program is also offered in a flexible and convenient format that allows working professionals to pursue an advanced degree without putting their lives on hold. You can immediately apply what you learn in your coursework directly to your everyday workplace responsibilities, solidifying your understanding through real-world application.

Request more information about our online M.L.S. (General Track) by reaching out to our team today. You can also get started with your application for admission here.

Interested in more specialized tracks? Our online M.L.S. is also offered with the following tracks:

  • Healthcare Law and Regulation
  • Law and Technology: Cybersecurity, Information Privacy, and AI
  • Employment Law and Human Resources Risk Management
  • Real Estate and Construction Law and Regulation
  • Wealth Management and Financial Services Law
Sources

Top